Why brands are turning creators into ad producers
Brands are increasingly paying creators not only to reach their followers, but also to develop the video and still-image assets used in paid campaigns. The shift reflects rising demand for social creative and positions creators as part of the advertising production supply chain, rather than solely as media partners or ambassadors.
“You get the authentic, scroll-stopping content that people want to engage with. But you also get the reach,” said Katy Ball, head of social at M&C Saatchi Sport & Entertainment.
More paid social investment, particularly in video, is increasing the need for creative that can fill those placements. A CreativeX study of 115,990 ad campaigns, representing $11 billion in ad spend, found that the number of assets associated with individual campaigns has grown 30% in five years. Yet an average campaign directs 88% of its media investment to just five assets, according to the study.
That growing need for campaign assets is helping drive what research consultancy Madison & Wall describes as the fastest-growing segment of the creator economy: spending on creator-led production. Its report says 12% of the $112 billion spent on creators globally currently goes toward creators producing ads for brands. The report projects that share of spending will grow 16% annually through 2030.
Production expands the creator relationship
Creator-led production covers several related arrangements. A brand may pay a creator a fee to make video or still assets for use in a campaign, without necessarily buying access to the creator’s audience. Another approach is whitelisting, also called dark advertising. In that arrangement, a creator gives a brand limited access to their social account so the brand can run paid campaigns through it, using creator-made assets and applying audience targeting.
Olivia Wedderburn, head of influence at Born Social, said some brands are reallocating media spending toward creator development to fund whitelisting. Madison & Wall’s research also points to possible funding from PR, social and experimental budgets, as well as conventional media and production budgets.
User-generated content is another related model: brands pay ordinary social media users to license their content for advertising. Andy Ryan, co-founder of social and influencer agency Komodo, said brands are looking to open additional routes for supplying their content operations.
The appeal, according to industry practitioners, includes the relative cost of working with creators compared with production agencies. Marketers are also trying to make non-media spending go further. While some are exploring generative AI for production, others are directing funds to creators.
Creator work can bring a different kind of creative judgment to an ad, said Jared Kozel, co-founder and chief creative officer at agency Super Nice. Paying for space in a creator’s feed does not itself guarantee audience attention, he said; creators understand what their audiences care about and how to make material worth stopping for.
Rights and fees are becoming more important
As creator-made assets become a larger part of campaigns, marketers need to manage how those assets can be used. Wedderburn said negotiating usage rights and exclusivity has become more complicated. The terms matter especially when brands want to run content beyond its original social context or for an extended period.
Billion Dollar Boy recently added features to its Companion creator-management tool to support creator-led production and usage-rights negotiations. Thomas Walters, the agency’s co-founder and chief innovation officer, said increased competition in the creator economy makes it more urgent for brands to understand the market.
Demand for expanded rights is also affecting creator rates. Agency practitioners reported last year that some creator fees had risen 10% to 20% as brands sought broader usage rights.
There is evidence that creator-made work can compete with conventional advertising in social environments. A report published in June by System1, WPP Media and Goat found that creator ads delivered 3.2 times the brand-awareness lift of category-leader ads made with traditional advertising creative. Wedderburn said some brands see creator assets as more valuable for conversion and reach than quickly produced materials they previously relied on.
Creator content may also feel more native to platforms such as TikTok and Instagram because it uses familiar visual cues, language and production styles. Nicholas Spiro, chief commercial officer at Viral Nation, said well-planned creator programs can produce more volume and variety, faster and at lower cost than traditional production cycles. He added that brands are beginning to plan creator activity across media budgets rather than treating it only as a separate influencer line item.
For marketers, the shift means creator partnerships increasingly involve production planning, paid distribution and rights management alongside talent selection. The opportunity to generate varied social assets comes with a need to define usage terms clearly and account for creator fees as demand grows.
