How retailers can add holiday value without relying on discounts

src-d16b128a

Holiday promotions do not have to make a lower price the main reason to buy. Retailers can build perceived value through email offers, loyalty benefits, clear delivery information and reassuring service policies—while avoiding the margin cost of discounts applied to every order.

The opportunity comes amid forecasts for higher holiday spending, though inflation complicates the picture. The National Retail Federation expects holiday sales to grow 4.2% to $1.013 trillion, while Adobe projects online spending will increase 6.7% to $275.1 billion. Those increases do not necessarily mean shoppers will buy more: higher prices account for a meaningful share of the projected growth, and customers may be paying more for the same or smaller baskets.

A discount can make a purchase feel like a better deal, but repeated markdowns can also condition customers to wait for the next promotion. An illustrative midsize home and kitchen retailer, with about $200 million in annual revenue, shows how brands could change the value proposition across the shopping journey. Its loyalty program currently functions mainly as a channel for distributing promo codes.

Make promotional email about more than a markdown

In the example, the retailer has six holiday email sends planned through Dec. 20, four of which lead with percentage-off offers. When a calendar repeats that pattern year after year, customers may learn to disregard full-price messages and wait for a later offer. The issue is not simply how many emails a brand sends, but whether each send has a clear purpose beyond driving immediate revenue.

Retailers can use email to communicate benefits that preserve the headline price. Loyalty members might receive early access to products, giving them a chance to shop before popular stock runs out. A bundle pairing a featured product with a complementary, slower-moving item can add perceived value without reducing the price of the main product. Loyalty points could also be exchanged for services such as priority shipping, gift wrapping or a dedicated returns line.

These benefits require operational planning, but they give campaign teams alternatives to making every message a discount announcement. In the illustrative calendar, the retailer replaces two of its four percentage-off sends with a members-first-access campaign and a bundle announcement, while retaining the other two discount promotions. The aim is not to eliminate markdowns, but to prevent them from becoming the only reason to open an email.

Email can also direct shoppers to useful product information. Showing store-level inventory helps customers decide whether a local visit is worthwhile, rather than leaving them to discover in person that an item is unavailable. That information is most helpful when the retailer can keep it accurate across its digital and physical operations.

Use certainty to reduce purchase hesitation

At checkout, delivery and returns information can address practical concerns without cutting the price. Narvar’s 2026 holiday survey with eTail Insights found that 70% of shoppers considered an accurate delivery date at checkout very important, ranking it as their top consideration. Reliable delivery dates also ranked within four points of price as a purchase driver. Kenco’s peak season report found that 82% of consumers considered return policies important or very important.

Those findings point to reassurance as a component of the offer. In the example, a competitor discounts overlapping cookware, small appliances and gift sets by 20% in the week before Thanksgiving. Rather than matching that promotion, the retailer offers a price-match guarantee through Dec. 24, refunding the difference if customers find the same item for less elsewhere. It also extends the return window through Jan. 31 and displays arrival dates based on carrier cutoff times, alongside live store inventory.

These policies are not cost-free. A price match can require a refund, extended returns can lead to more returned merchandise, and delivery promises depend on fulfillment performance. But their costs arise when customers use the protections, unlike a blanket discount that reduces revenue on every order covered by the offer—including purchases that might have happened at full price. In the illustrative scenario, the additional returns are described as small in number and mostly exchanges; that is an assumption in the example, not a general result for retailers.

Coordinate campaigns with operations

The value of a delivery promise depends on the warehouse and carriers meeting it. A return extension needs a clear process, and a price-match guarantee needs finance to support its terms. Marketing teams cannot make those commitments credible through email copy alone.

Retailers therefore need marketing, finance and operations to plan together before the busiest period, rather than waiting until January to review delivery problems or a returns increase. For email teams, that coordination also makes it possible to promote benefits with confidence: early access requires a plan for inventory, and delivery messaging needs reliable dates.

Discounts remain one tool in the holiday toolkit. But a more balanced program can use email to highlight access, useful bundles and loyalty services, then reinforce the purchase with accurate fulfillment details and clear policies. The result is a value proposition built around the full customer experience—not solely the price reduction.