Brands use different creator labels, complicating measurement and budgets

src-c9b0af1e

Brands and agencies are still using different definitions for creators, influencers and related partnership roles, making it harder to compare campaigns and establish consistent expectations for measurement and cost. As creator investment grows, marketers are seeking clearer ways to describe what partners do and what results they are expected to deliver.

At least 23% of marketers say the industry would benefit from a unified creator taxonomy, according to the IAB’s latest creator economy report. Yet current approaches vary widely, including within the same broad category of creator marketing. Some organizations sort partners by audience size; others emphasize cultural relevance or the role a creator plays in a campaign.

Brands build their own creator tiers

General Mills uses a tiered framework that runs from celebrity partnerships to smaller, more organic advocates. Director of influencer and content Mindy Murray described the boundary between a celebrity and a mega influencer as increasingly unclear.

At the top of General Mills’ framework are celebrity partnerships, which may extend beyond social media into product design or formulation. Mega creators sit below that level. The company defines mid-tier creators as having between 500,000 and 1.5 million social media followers. Its system also includes dedicated creators who post regularly on the brand’s behalf, as well as friends and family who serve as organic advocates.

Shutterfly uses three broad labels. Tastemakers have at least one million followers and are selected for major campaigns. Content creators can have anywhere from a few hundred to more than 2,000 followers, while influencers sit between those groups, according to Callie Worthington, the company’s vice president of brand marketing and creative.

Those labels do not correspond to a fixed internal pay scale at Shutterfly. Worthington said larger creators, including tastemakers and influencers, are expected to require larger budgets. The distinction illustrates how audience-based definitions can inform planning without necessarily dictating a standardized rate.

Rothy’s also uses the term tastemaker, but its classifications put less emphasis on follower counts and more on cultural relevance. A tastemaker could be a TikTok star or a Substack writer, said Anna Doré, the shoe brand’s vice president of brand and communications. Rothy’s separately describes affiliate creators as lower-funnel, conversion-focused partners.

Agencies focus on what creators do

VML takes a more role-based approach, organizing creators according to their contribution to a campaign. That can include salespeople, brand ambassadors and product collaborators. Noah Eisemann, VML’s global executive director of creator and influencer, said the agency’s taxonomy is not especially rigid.

In his view, every influencer is a creator, but not every creator is an influencer. The distinction matters as brand partnerships extend beyond product promotion on social platforms. Creators may appear as actors in major advertising spots, collaborate on products, or help brands develop and execute creative work. The same person can fit different categories depending on the assignment.

That flexibility challenges systems built around a single label or follower threshold. A person’s audience size can be relevant, but it may not explain whether a campaign is hiring that person to reach customers, shape a product, represent a brand or develop creative. Eisemann argued that a more useful shared standard would define the role a creator is playing in a particular strategy, since that role should inform both valuation and success criteria.

Inconsistent definitions affect investment decisions

Creator classifications influence how partners are evaluated, how campaigns are measured and where they are used. When brands, agencies and creators apply different assumptions to a partnership, expectations around results and budgets can diverge. That may make effective work harder to recognize and future investment more difficult to justify, said Stefani Stamatiou, CEO of the Americas at creator marketing agency HYDP.

The lack of common terminology also connects to broader standardization challenges. Marketers have been working to align practices such as what counts as a view, the language used in brand-creator contracts and the structures used to set deal fees. A shared taxonomy alone would not resolve each issue, but clearer definitions could help establish what is being bought and how performance should be assessed.

As more money flows into the creator economy, marketers are asking for measurable business outcomes. Stamatiou said clearer inputs and expected outcomes would help teams set goals, allocate budgets and define creators’ place in the broader advertising mix. For now, there is no conventional industry naming system, leaving companies to determine which distinctions matter for their own strategies.